• 0 Posts
  • 188 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 11th, 2023

help-circle

  • Oh boy, you really bought into the very one sided view of this conflict. There would also not have been the Iran war without Iran having the elimination of the state Israel as an official state target for the last 40 years. Neither would there have been an October 7th with the following Gaza war. Or the Hisbollah which makes Lebanon a failed state just like that as a side note if Iran’s state policy to eliminate Israel. And the list goes on and can also be told in very one sided fashion. I’ll leave that to the Netanyahus because I see no point in one sided extremism.

    But as you quite clearly layed out, you wholely buy into the world view of the arab led anti Israeli movement, which is extremist and a nicely packaged antisemitic world view for righteous leftists, but in essence really only repeats tropes that were told about Jews for centuries. You managed to expose that much better than I ever could.

    Unfortunately you still have no idea what I am talking about. I suggest to look into the history of antisemitism before the state of Israel was founded, or even better, before 1900. Maybe you will see a pattern then. In short, Jews always were themselves responsible for antisemitism, because they existed.

    As a side note, you totally managed to distract from China. Good job. I thought it really hypocritical to bring an unrelated conflict into the Trump Xi comparison, blaming Trump for Israel (which is laughable because that conflict is much older) while totally ignoring the crimes against humanity that China subjects the Uighurs to under Xi himself. (Another alleged genocide by states and NGOs without a ICC ruling)




  • Wtf you are laying words into my mouth that I never said. I am claiming antisemitism where antisemitic patterns are used, and you did that by implicitly naming it as undifferentiated evil.

    I denounce the antisemitism of the fascist crowd of which MAGA is part of in the same way as I do on the left. It’s there even if you don’t see it. If you don’t want to be accused of antisemitism don’t use antisemitic tropes. And if you don’t know what I mean go educate yourself.

    I also denounce the war crimes and large scale crimes against humanity of the Israel government.

    But I am careful enough with my words that I don’t include all the civilians and the opposition as well. Are you? You weren’t up there the comment thread where you dropped the name as equivalent for an ultimate evil.








  • His imperial and antidemocratic features manifest a bit differently, and he has no need for that open corruption, because he is indistinguishable from the party and therefore from the state. Fine. He also has much more grounded ideological background than Trump, as the other commenter pointed out. But then, Putin has that one too. As did Mussolini. This does not make anyone a good human.

    After all that he’s still an imperial and antidemocratic autocrat. I’m not very picky with my words. Sorry if the term dictator offended you.