• 0 Posts
  • 6 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 8th, 2023

help-circle
  • Yeah, I mean I don’t see how you could make the case that providing Israel defensive weapons (which, setting aside that they shouldn’t be trusted not to find a way to use them offensively, has the direct and immediate effect of strengthening the continued existence of the genocidal state and thus its ability to continue the genocide) is simply harm reduction. It’d be great if there were a way to dismantle the Israeli state to the extent that they no longer have the capability to carry out a genocide while simultaneously protecting Israeli children from the few attempts Hamas has made at resisting the genocide. I’d support that. But it’s idealistic given our current reality. We can work towards it, but in the meantime, if we want to mitigate the most harm, we need to be taking power and capability away from the genocidal state wherever it exists–including its “defensive” weapons.





  • Ah, we’re on to Chapter 2 of the playbook. “Tell me where you think I’m wrong so I can regurgitate Daddy Marx gospel about why it’s actually the undeniable truth.”

    In case you’re actually engaging in good faith, you (MLs, collectively) do this thing where because you see everything through the scientific lens of historical materialism, you can’t really acknowledge or refute differing philosophical interpretations of historical facts beyond dismissing them as bourgeoisie propaganda. Which like, you’re right a lot of the time! Particularly when it comes to western thought and mainstream interpretations of history. But then you have situations like this, where two sociopathic world powers are fighting each other via competing interpretations of history that both just serve to keep the respective ruling people in power. And it’s like you can’t let go of the idea that the power that most represents capitalism has to be the single villain in a good vs. evil fight in every conflict it gets into. So you state facts about the west’s villainy, which are true, but then you get angry when someone questions what the U.S. being a villain has to do with the villainy of the other party–do things like imply they’re stupid or didn’t read what you said, when really they just have a more nuanced understanding of the world than you do.